Re: voting or no voting.. (HospitalityGuide.net - Site / Forum)

posted by torstenhilipp , Dresden, 31.08.2006, 18:33

one more thing about voting that came to my mind: it gives people more direct influence and they start to think more deeply about what they have to vote about.

if i´d tell the editors "come on give zero points to cs because they recently wrecked all the data" we´d maybe have an arguement about this and in the end i wouldn´t see any influence from my suggestion and feel as a looser. if people vote they can see their influence even if they didn´t "win".

than again i know what you mean with the bad experiences from wikis, so maybe we should wait with votings till there are enough capacities for conflict solution. on the other hand: such capacities don´t fall from the sky


somehow the votes shouldn´t be valid till the end of the world, i mean people change and so do opinions.

» Hi Thorsten,
»
» » first of all i was thinking about the ranking of the networks. till now
» it
» » seems rather based upon individual experiences.
»
» The ranking of the networks is based on the editorial part of Hosp.Ex Ne>t
» (although it isn't up to date right now anymore and needs some attention)
» and that is the special thing about Hosp.Ex Ne>t. On the
» Wiki
» and
» here
» on the forum are some public discussions about how we could create
» and use some objective measurement in the rating. Also ideas and thoughts
» from the Wiki (wich is open to everybody and I also tell everybody, who
» states fore example that here is false information on Hosp.Ex Ne>t, to
» edit instead to complain) can be taken over into this and we are very open
» to all ideas and points made. But as we had quite bad experiences with
» information out Wikis and given on the Networks (I'm sure the same will
» happen when you Vote about the rating of the Networks, as for example most
» people don't know much about all the other pages), we decided for the
» editorial team who stands behind the given information, so everybody can
» judge about it themselves. We hope that we can expand this 'expertise' in
» the future.
»
» » but i´m also not sure about voting at all.
»
» I think at some points it would be good to have a voting - let's keep it
» in mind.
»
» .alex

Complete thread:

• update soon.. :) - 'lex, 15.01.2006, 15:12 (HospitalityGuide.net - Site / Forum)
  • preview hosp.ex ne>t v1.. - 'lex, 15.02.2006, 12:29
  • update soon.. :) - 'lex, 31.08.2006, 00:47
    • update soon.. :) - torstenhilipp, 31.08.2006, 10:39
      • update soon.. :) - 'lex, 31.08.2006, 12:10
        • update soon.. :) - torstenhilipp, 31.08.2006, 13:30
          • update soon.. :) - jeldridge, 31.08.2006, 13:40
            • Re: spreading Hosp.Ex Ne>t.. - 'lex, 31.08.2006, 15:41
          • Re: voting or no voting.. - 'lex, 31.08.2006, 15:30
            • Re: voting or no voting.. - torstenhilipp, 31.08.2006, 18:33
  • Pictures Beta! All tips welcome.. - 'lex, 10.09.2006, 19:52
    • Pictures Beta! All tips welcome.. - jeldridge, 11.09.2006, 13:10
      • Pictures Beta! All tips welcome.. - 'lex, 11.09.2006, 14:51
        • Pictures Beta! All tips welcome.. - jeldridge, 12.09.2006, 09:42